
This is a twist on a traditional lemon meringue pie that I made last weekend for some friends. In order to make the curd (the filling) you start with a few Meyer lemons. Really, any lemons will do, but Meyer lemons are my absolute favorite. Their mellow flavor is unbeatable! Thanks to my wonderful friend, Andrea, I had a bunch of freshly picked lemons on my counter!

Wash them, then zest one large one before juicing enough of them (2 or 3) to make 1/2 cup of juice.

In the same pot as the zest, add 6 TBSP butter and 1/2 cup sugar and put it over low heat on your stove to melt. In another bowl whisk 3 eggs.

Now if you've never tempered eggs before, this can be a little bit tricky step. Hopefully my photos and explanation will help. Pour the lemon juice through a strainer into the butter and zest mixture. The strainer will catch any little seeds or pith that the juicer didn't get. Whisk the three ingredients until incorporated. Once the butter is melted completely, the mixture is ready to add to your eggs. Take a half cup of the hot butter mixture and while you are whisking the eggs (remember, they're in a separate bowl), you slowly pour in the hot liquid. Repeat that step, whisking the whole time (you don't want little pieces of cooked, scrambled eggs in your curd...yuk). Then take the whole egg mixture and slowly incorporate that back into your pan, whisking the butter mixture in the pan while you pour. Now you've got all your ingredients in one pot, the butter, sugar, juice, zest and eggs. Keep whisking over low heat until it starts to thicken into a custard.

To check if your curd is thick enough, dip in a spoon and if the curd coats and sticks to the back of your spoon, it's done. You are welcome to keep whisking if you want it a bit thicker (although it will thicken up a bit more as it cools). Remove from heat and let cool to room temperature before pouring into your pie shell. It won't fill the crust all the way. The curd is so rich, you only need a bit, it's more like the amount in a tart. If you want to know what pie crust I like to bake with, you can find the exact recipe and tutorial
here. This is the exact same recipe that my friend, Jane Harms, has used for years and was kind enough to share it with me when I got married. I'm not sure how Pioneer Woman got a hold of it, but her post, complete with pictures, is a big help when I want to share it with others! Put the pie crust, now filled with curd into the fridge to cool while we make the meringue.

Some cookbooks refer to this type of meringue as Italian. I actually got this recipe from a Mexican cookbook to top a tres leches cake. Either way, it's fabulous! And I don't even like traditional meringue.

In a standing mixer, beat 3 egg whites and 1/4 tsp cream of tartar until soft peaks form (about 4-6 min). Add 3 TBSP sugar and beat another 8-10 minutes, until stiff peaks form. Check to make sure your sugar is fully dissolved into your egg whites by taking a bit in your fingertips and rubbing to make sure it doesn't feel gritty (since I used raw cane sugar, this was an important step).

While your egg whites are beating, put a saucepan on the stove over high heat. Combine 1/2 cup water, 3/4 cup + 1 TBSP sugar and 1/4 tsp cream of tartar. Cover and cook for two minutes. Uncover and cook for about 6 minutes more, or until the mixture reaches the soft-ball stage (239 degrees on a candy thermometer). Since I don't have a candy thermometer I dip a spoon into the mixture after the 8 minutes and get a bit of the syrup and drop it into a cup of cold water. The syrup will turn into a gooey soft ball if it's at the right stage. Don't walk away from your pot when making a candy syrup! It can go past the proper stage quickly and you'll have to start all over again!

Once the syrup is at the right stage, grab the pot off your stove, turn your standing mixer back onto high, and pour the hot syrup into the beaten egg white mixture. Beat until it is back to room temperature and glossy, soft peaks form (about 5 minutes). I used only half of this meringue on the pie, which I thought was a perfect amount to balance the tart lemon curd, but you are welcome to use it all...pile it high! With a wet rubber spatula, spread the meringue onto your pie (which has had a good half hour now in the fridge). Turn the broiler in your oven to low. Because the eggs in this meringue already cooked because of the hot sugar syrup, you don't need to cook it, but a little browning of the meringue gives it a nice toasty flavor! Place the pie on the top rack of your oven and broil for 1 minute. If it doesn't look toasty enough, give it another 30 seconds, watching it the entire time...that would be HORRIBLE to ruin your pie on the last step.

If making a pie seems like way too much work, you can always just make the lemon curd and enjoy it atop your favorite biscuit, scone, or toast! In fact, I doubled the curd recipe so I'd have leftovers and I used it this morning on top of some raspberry scones. Delicious!
Curd recipe adapted from
Nigella Lawson's cookbook, How to Be a Domestic Goddess. Meringue recipe from
Steven Raichlen's Healthy Latin Cooking.